Guitar Doubling Basics
How To Get a Fat Guitar Sound
When people refer to a sound as being "fat" they usually mean different realities and consequently different practices. Here is an overview of the techniques most commonly used to easily get a fat sound. In this first article, we'll focus on guitars, which gives us the opportunity to discuss guitar doubling techniques.
In many music genres, from rock to metal, a guitar is expected to have a massive and fat sound so that it fills the whole sound field... It's even expected to sound bigger than life like in Metallica's Enter Sandman, the White Stripes' Seven Nation Army, Almighty's Wrench, Queens of the Stone Age's No One Knows, Springsteen's Radio Nowhere or Rage Against the Machine's Killing in the Name, to name just a few. People who are not well versed in guitar sound often imagine that it's all a matter of amp size and output power, loudness or the gain/drive of a distortion or fuzz effect pedal.
Although these different factors do have an effect on sound, they don't guarantee a fat guitar sound. The proof? The Pignose! This tiny traveling amp had a ridiculous output power; however it was used by Frank Zappa in the following video:
This is not really an example of a fat sound like in the songs mentioned above, but it shows that when it comes to the sound of a guitar...
Size doesn't matter!
It would indeed be very stupid to assert that the low-frequency response of a 4x12 cabinet or the natural compression of a 100-watt head when it is cranked up aren't something to consider seriously when recording. But remember that, regardless of the output power and the loudness in front of the microphone, the track won't be louder. In fact, you'll have to decrease the gain of your microphone preamp to avoid clipping, and in the end you'll end up with the same signal level as with a 5-watt amp.
Moreover, increasing the distortion on your amp or stompboxes won't bring better results either... Here is the proof: listen to the riff in Every Breath you Take by The Police. The guitar tone is fairly clean but it still sounds very wide.
The same applies to the acoustic guitar part in Avril Lavigne's Complicated:
In short, this wide and full sound you like so much in some recordings is not a question of output power nor loudness or distortion amount. Or, to put it in other, more precise words, these factors won't guarantee a fat sound.
So what now?
Clean guitar tracks are often compressed in order to control the attacks, emphasize the sustain of the instrument or give consistency to a rhythm guitar track. It's a bit different with distorted guitar tracks: the amp's or stompobox's distortion tends to naturally compress the dynamic response of the signal, so it's not necessary to compress it further. When it comes to audio ─ and especially compression ─ less is often more, so avoid overdoing things.
A fat sound means that the guitar fills the whole sound field as if it were always set at maximum.
You must obviously consider several factors when it comes to a fat guitar sound. For example, you can compress your guitar tracks to reduce their dynamic range and emphasize their role within the mix, like INXS did with the guitar riff in I Need You Tonight. But apart from compression, which is especially effective with clean guitar sounds (see text box), the most effective and common way to fatten a guitar part is doubling.
I'm hearing double!
The idea is quite simple: if you want a guitar part to sound fat, record it a second time to an additional track. Do note that I said "record" it again. Don't just duplicate it by copy-pasting it in your sequencer because that won't achieve the expected effect. So play the guitar part twice and record it on two different tracks. Maybe you think you'll get two completely or almost identical guitar tracks, but there are thousands of micro-variations between both tracks that fatten the sound once they are mixed together.
This effect is based on the good old unison principle you can hear in choirs, in the strings of a symphonic orchestra or in the singing of supporters in a soccer stadium. The fact that several persons play or sing exactly the same thing produces a richer sound, which most people will describe as more powerful, even if loudness has no influence here.
Listen to the single guitar, then to the doubled guitar:
Real or virtual amp? Or both?
Note that doubling guitar parts works as good with real amps as with virtual amps, and nothing keeps you from combining both. This explains why many studios are equipped with POD or Eleven amps and myriads of amp simulations. They are very useful for doubling applications because they provide a very wide sound range while being easy to use.
The sound turns a bit fatter, even if it's not obvious. But we're only starting. Now your guitar tracks sound fatter because they fill the audio spectrum a bit more than with a single guitar. But they will sound even bigger if you spread them across the stereo image.
Listen to the result when one track is panned at 10 o'clock and the other at 2 o'clock.
Better, isn't it? And why not take it even further? Fatter than doubling? Tripling, quadrupling, etc. Pan all your tracks to cover the stereo field and you'll get an impressive guitar wall.
But be careful! Even though you can frequently see productions where the guitar has been recorded six times, excessive doubling becomes counterproductive: instead of getting always fatter, the sound becomes less precise and flanging effects appear here and there. In a way, better becomes the enemy of good:
Moreover, your song most likely won't include only a guitar part, so keep in mind that the other instruments also need their own space...
Doubling with a computer
Brainworx's bx_shredspread is a clever tool that provides extremely intuitive guitar doubling management in terms of EQ and pan settings, while keeping monitoring phase problems and ensuring mono compatibility thanks to M/S processing. All for only $99...
Just settle for four guitar tracks and focus on all available possibilities you have to fatten the sound, like using different and complementary guitar sounds. Remember that one of the goals of a "fat" sound is to fill the frequency spectrum, so it's easy to understand why it can be interesting to combine a rather dull guitar that has lots of lows with a rather bright guitar that has more high frequencies. In short, combine different colors to get a richer sound.
And there are many ways to experience: change the selected pickup on your guitar, or change the guitar itself, use different amps, different microphones in different positions... And don't forget the sound variations that your amp provides and the 1001 stompboxes you could insert in the signal chain.
The following example combines two takes recorded with the neck pickup of the guitar plus two takes recorded with the bridge pickup.
This example combines recordings made with different microphones on the speaker:
Now, let's see what happens when using different guitars (Les Paul plus Telecaster):
And finally with two different amps:
Take, for example, the very typically American production of Joan Osbourne's One of Us. In the chorus there are distorted guitars left and right in the stereo field but you can also hear a tiny guitar with a sharp distortion that recalls a beehive right in the middle. This kind of lo-fi touch sharpens the overall fat sound in the high-frequency range.
A tip for distorted guitars: the more you double the parts, the more you lose intelligibility. So it's very important to play as cleanly as possible with precise attacks and a perfect timing. Keeping a guitar track clean will help you have more detailed attacks.
The case of acoustic and clean guitars
Regardless of its type (folk, concert or Gypsy), acoustic guitars also sound fuller when they are doubled. But since they produce stronger transients and less sustain ─ in other words they sound more detailed than distorted guitars─, be careful with doubling because you can lose intelligibility very quickly. This being said, you can experience with both acoustic and electric guitars by combining different instruments and different microphone positions.
Listen to the single guitar, then to the doubled guitar:
You can also try mixed solutions. For example, combine an acoustic with an electric guitar like the Doobie Brothers in the famous riff of Long Train Running.
Listen to the result with our example (doubling with an electro-acoustic guitar, then with an electric guitar):
In an all-electric situation, doubling works also very well with clean arpeggios:
Those tiny variations that make the difference
When doubling a guitar part, you play the same thing twice and record two different tracks. But it could be interesting to introduce some very subtle variations, like different chord positions. You can play a D chord on the first three frets and then double it by playing a D chord at the 5th fret. You can transpose the chords one octave up or down, a technique often used with acoustic guitars in country music. You can also enrich the harmony by doubling a major chord with a major7 chord, although such solutions are more an arrangement than merely sound production.
For example, listen to Fight's Kill It where the guitar parts are doubled and an additional guitar comes on the top to fatten the riff and enrich the harmony:
And now with our guitar part, listen how different chord positions of a same chord or transposing an octave enrich the sound:
It is up to you to decide how to combine these different techniques to fatten your guitar parts. A whole new world is now open for you to experiment ─ and this is all the more true considering that doubling also applies to other signal sources. But that's something we'll discuss in a future article.