Become a member
Become a member
Continuer avec Google

or
Log in
Log in
Se connecter avec Google

or
learning

Doing away with the complexes

The ultimate guide to audio recording - Part 60

This week I will digress a bit to reflect upon recorded music and demystify it all a bit...

View other articles in this series...

Make the best of what you've got…

Have you ever searched the web high and low for a live or unreleased version of your favorite songs? Do you put the same commercially unavailable recordings in loop until exhaustion? If you are a music lover – which you probably are, otherwise you wouldn't be reading this –, you have surely answered "Yes!" to both questions above. I certainly do. Like with this version of a Thom Yorke song which was unavailable on any album until recently:

Don't you think it's paradoxical that audio lovers can achieve a state of ecstasy listening to such poor quality recordings? I don't, because music always comes before sound quality to me. When I have such whims, technical quality doesn't play a role as long as the performance exudes emotion. What's my point, you ask? Well, basically that the recording gear you use and how good you are at using it is not that important when you are dealing with Art with a capital "A" – and this comes from someone who makes a living working as an audio engineer!

You are not convinced? You think that my argument is bogus because nobody would ever pay for such a recording when you can get it for free online? Well, music lovers from the second half of the 20th century, like myself, think the complete opposite. Chances are such people have spent lots of time at their favorite indie record stores looking for bootlegs to satisfy their crave for "new" music. But anyway. Maybe the following examples are more convincing....

Did you know that Beck's famous smash hit Loser was produced on a very low budget? And Roman Candle, the superb first album of the late Elliot Smith, was entirely recorded on a four-track recorder in the basement of his girlfriend back then. If you don't know this masterpiece, there's the eponymous song:

Not bad is it?

Many people consider that the best songs on Jeff Buckley's posthumous second album are his last demos recorded on a 4-track cassette recorder. Here's a clip I'm particularly fond of:

And even "The Boss" himself released an album back in '82 entirely recorded on a cheap tape recorder, which didn't stop Nebraska from selling millions of copies worldwide. And you mustU+0020admit that it really rocks, as you can attest here:

It's not uncommon to hear some people say that if these artists had had the chance to record these songs under better conditions, they would've surely done it to get a more transcendental result. Well, I'm not entirely sure. Jeff Buckley would've certainly preferred to live longer and go into the studio to record, but what can I say, the urge to swim was stronger even if, as it turned out, he wasn't the best of swimmers.

The recording conditions could be a matter of dispute in the case of Beck and Smith, but certainly not with Mr. Springsteen. Actually, he did go into the studio with the E Street Band to re-record the entire album in question, but in the end he decided to release the demo versions. Enlightening, isn't it?

One last example that illustrates perfectly my point that the gear you use is only secondary is Ed Harcourt. Mr. Harcourt became famous with the Maplewood EP which he, too, recorded on a 4-track at his granma's back in 2000. And this is the best-known track:

The least you can say is that he had a good ear and knew how to get an interesting sound despite his lack of means. However, Harcourt thought it would be a good idea to re-record this track for his first album co-produced by Tim Holmes (Death in Vegas). And this is what came out:

I don't know about you, but to my ears this "remake" is certainly not as good as the original version. It is definitely "cleaner," but I find it a bit dull in comparison to the original performance. Granted, this is entirely subjective, but it does make you wonder, doesn't it?

And why did I think it was a good idea to mention it within this recording series? Because many people out there think that the lack of gear and/or technical expertise are an unsurmountable barrier when it comes to artistic expression. Well, I beg to differ. And that's why I take any chance I get to debunk this misconception which I think is utterly wrong. To me, music is the gift and the recording is only the packaging. My job as an audio engineer is to make the best possible packaging with the means I have at my disposal, nothing more and nothing less. But the "beauty" of this packaging shouldn't affect the gifts inside in the slightest. And don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that you shouldn't do your best when it comes to the packaging. That's actually the main goal of this series. I'm only trying to demystify recording so you can go out there and do your thing without having to worry about this "secondary" issue.

And with these words I say goodbye until next time when we will continue our adventures in recording!

← Previous article in this series:
Recording bass guitar - Naming names
Next article in this series:
Talking mics →
  • Airlane1979 3 posts
    Airlane1979
    New AFfiliate
    Posted on 01/13/2018 at 10:26:48
    A good piece, showing the need for talent before gear. In my case, I have no talent at all and only a little bit of gear. Oh well. I should give it to a charity.
  • Ellementine 8 posts
    Ellementine
    New AFfiliate
    Posted on 01/17/2018 at 18:01:08
    No. Those recordings were ghetto. Intelligible, but ghetto. And they don't count because they're just voice and guitar - except that last one where it did have more instruments and sounded awful. Kick drum sounded like those 50s thunder get-ups.

Vous souhaitez réagir à cet article ?

Log in
Become a member
cookies

We are using cookies!

Yes, Audiofanzine is using cookies. Since the last thing that we want is disturbing your diet with too much fat or too much sugar, you'll be glad to learn that we made them ourselves with fresh, organic and fair ingredients, and with a perfect nutritional balance. What this means is that the data we store in them is used to enhance your use of our website as well as improve your user experience on our pages (learn more). To configure your cookie preferences, click here.

We did not wait for a law to make us respect our members and visitors' privacy. The cookies that we use are only meant to improve your experience on our website.

Our cookies

Cookies not subject to consent

These are cookies that guarantee the proper functioning of Audiofanzine and allow its optimization. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.

Website preferences

We store your preferences so that you do not have to re-enter them every time your come back (forums options, dark or light theme, classifieds filter, standard or buzz news, newsletters popups...).

Log in

This one makes sure you don't have to re-enter your credentials every time you visit Audiofanzine.

Analytics

This data allows us to understand the use that our visitors make of our website in an attempt to improve it.

Advertising

This information allows us to show you personalized advertisements thanks to which Audiofanzine is financed. By unchecking this box you will still have advertisements but they may be less interesting :)

We did not wait for a law to make us respect our members and visitors' privacy. The cookies that we use are only meant to improve your experience on our website.

Our cookies

Cookies not subject to consent

These are cookies that guarantee the proper functioning of Audiofanzine and allow its optimization. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.

Website preferences

We store your preferences so that you do not have to re-enter them every time your come back (forums options, dark or light theme, classifieds filter, standard or buzz news, newsletters popups...).

Log in

This one makes sure you don't have to re-enter your credentials every time you visit Audiofanzine.

Analytics

This data allows us to understand the use that our visitors make of our website in an attempt to improve it.

Advertising

This information allows us to show you personalized advertisements thanks to which Audiofanzine is financed. By unchecking this box you will still have advertisements but they may be less interesting :)


You can find more details on data protection in our privacy policy.